Skip to content
Company Data Advisors

Blog

Can a law firm license its files to AI buyers?

· Company Data Advisors

AI data buyers want closed-matter files from law firms, but Rule 1.6 covers all information about a client. What buyers ask for and what to settle first.

In our view, possibly, but a law firm cannot answer it by asking what buyers want, because buyers want plenty. Under the ABA's Model Rule 1.6, a lawyer may not reveal information relating to the representation of a client without the client's informed consent, and that duty covers more than privileged material. Mercor publishes a listing for complete files from closed matters and says it needs client consent or documents that can be fully anonymized. So the real gating question is which of a firm's records are the firm's own and which are its clients'.

This is a reading of public sources, not legal or ethics advice. Your state's version of the rules is what binds you, so have counsel or your bar's ethics hotline review before you share anything with a buyer, including a sample.

What do AI data buyers want from law firms?

AI data buyers want records that show legal work being done: pleadings, contracts, deal documents and the correspondence around them. Legal is one of the industries counted in our November demand map. The table shows eight of the programs in our buyer index that name legal work or legal records, as of November 8, and what each says.

Buyer What it names for legal Size or limit it states
Mercor A law firm listing: complete files from closed matters and completed transactions 5 to 300 attorneys and staff; 5 or more years of closed matters; US preferred
Mode Legal as a named group, with a lower minimum than other businesses 6 or more employees
Collinear Legal matters, contracts and legal billing About 50 or more people fits best
Turing Legal and contracts among its strongest areas Not stated
SourceX Legal contracts among its data types 50 or more full-time employees at peak
Scale AI Legal and compliance among its industries 40 or more preferred
Handshake Legal among its industries 20 or more full-time employees and 3 or more years in operation
Replay Legal among the industries it works with Ties its range to headcount

Sources for each row are on the buyer's page in our index, which links to the program's own page. Mercor's law firm listing is the most specific. It asks for pleadings and discovery productions from concluded litigation and data rooms and contracts from completed transactions, says single matters with hundreds or thousands of documents are the most valuable, and wants matters with 500 or more documents. It names Relativity, Everlaw, iManage, NetDocuments and Clio as tools it works with. Mercor says what the company earns on this listing is $50K to $1.2M, depending on matter size and completeness, in its published range, which is not a quote or a promise.

Mode sets its employee minimum at 6 for legal, 10 for accounting, finance and medical, and 30 for everything else, so a small practice fits Mode where a company of the same size in most other fields does not. Collinear lists legal matters, contracts and legal billing among the areas it is buying now.

What does Rule 1.6 cover?

Rule 1.6(a) of the ABA Model Rules says a lawyer "shall not reveal information relating to the representation of a client" unless the client gives informed consent, the disclosure is impliedly authorized to carry out the representation, or an exception in paragraph (b) applies. In our reading, none of the paragraph (b) exceptions fits a data license; ask counsel. Two points in the official comment matter most for a firm weighing one:

  • It is broader than privilege. Comment [3] says the confidentiality rule applies not only to matters communicated in confidence by the client but to "all information relating to the representation, whatever its source." On our reading, a public court filing in the matter is still part of that information.
  • Removing names may not be enough. Comment [4] says the prohibition also applies to disclosures that "do not in themselves reveal protected information but could reasonably lead to the discovery of such information by a third person." It allows a hypothetical only where there is no reasonable likelihood that the listener can work out the client or the situation.

Both come from the Model Rules, which are the ABA's template. Each state adopts its own version, and the wording can differ.

Do closed matters and former clients change anything?

A closed matter is still covered. Comment [20] to Rule 1.6 says the duty of confidentiality continues after the client-lawyer relationship ends, and Rule 1.9(c) says a lawyer who formerly represented a client, or whose present or former firm did, shall not reveal information relating to the representation except as the Rules would permit with respect to a client.

That matters because Mercor's listing is for concluded matters. In our reading, a five-year archive of closed litigation is an archive of former-client information under the Model Rules. Mercor's own listing reflects this: it excludes active matters and says it is not a fit for privileged material clients won't release.

Which of a law firm's records are candidates?

Our view: a law firm holds two bodies of records, and only one is a plausible starting point. The first is the firm's own business: how it bills, staffs and runs the practice. The second is client work: pleadings, productions, deal documents and any email that discusses a matter. The rules above mostly concern the second.

Records Our read Why it matters
Firm-authored templates, forms and practice guides with no client facts Candidate, after review Firm work product, but check that no client facts were left in
The firm's own billing, staffing and operations records Candidate, after review Firm information, but time entries and invoices can describe client matters
Closed-matter files, pleadings and productions Not without client consent Rules 1.6 and 1.9(c) apply, and productions may hold third parties' information, in our view
Email, chat and document-management exports Treat as mixed Firm business and client information often sit in the same threads
Active matters Leave out Mercor excludes them, and in our view the duty to current clients is at its strongest

This is a screening view, not a conclusion about any firm. The comment's reasoning, that information that could lead to a client's identity is protected even when the name is gone, is why the mixed category belongs on the cautious side. Mercor names client consent as one route, and asks whether clients would accept anonymized licensing, so check the firm's engagement terms on that question before you ask a buyer.

What about a firm that is closing?

In our reading, closing does not release the firm from these duties. Weil, Gotshal & Manges announced on October 28, 2026 that its management committee had recommended an orderly wind-down, with partners expected to vote in the following days. Dealroom reported, citing The Information, that the legal AI startup Crosby submitted a letter of intent on October 29 for some of Weil's assets, including its internal data, trademark and brand. Neither company had confirmed the bid, and its terms and how Crosby would use the data were not reported. We found no report of the partners' vote or the bid's outcome as of November 9.

We cite it as a sign of how AI companies now value the archives of failed firms, not as a template. What a given buyer could lawfully take from a closing firm is the same question this post is about: the firm's own records are one thing, and client files are another. Our guide to licensing company data when you are closing covers who signs and who is paid first.

What should a firm check before it applies?

Before applying, a law firm should settle whose information is in the files, who must consent and what the buyer will do with it.

  1. Sort the records by whose they are: firm, client or mixed. The table above is a starting point.
  2. Read your engagement letters for what clients agreed to about use of their information. Check whether any clause names a data license to an AI buyer; a general technology or vendor clause may not.
  3. Decide whether consent is realistic. If informed consent from each affected client is needed, ask whether you would request it and what that does to the relationship.
  4. Ask where de-identification happens. Mercor says it scopes the data, signs an NDA and runs the export, removing or protecting personal information, while Mode says it removes or transforms sensitive information before onward delivery. Given Comment [4], ask whether removal is enough for your files.
  5. Ask what the buyer can do onward, including what happens to a model trained on your records. Our terms comparison covers exclusivity and duration.
  6. Get counsel and your bar's ethics guidance involved first, and ask your professional liability carrier.

Where we come in

Company Data Advisors is an independent advisory firm. We track the published terms of every major program, have direct contacts at the major data buyers and at AI labs, and compare offers on the whole deal: price, exclusivity, how long the license runs, deletion and onward use. For a law firm, we can say which programs name legal records and what each states about size and limits, and compare how each describes de-identification. We cannot tell a firm whether its clients' consents are sufficient. That is a question for the firm's counsel.

Nothing about your company is shared until you approve a specific, named buyer. Participating buyers may pay us referral fees, and we tell you whether a buyer pays us before any introduction. Owners pay us nothing, and you can apply to any buyer directly.

What to do next

Start with the inventory, not the buyers. List the systems your firm runs on, mark each as firm, client or mixed, and take the list to counsel with the text of Rule 1.6 and your state's version of it. If a clean category remains, answer a few quick questions to see which programs it may fit, or read our guide on how to sell or license your company's data to AI companies for the steps from first form to payment. Accounting firms face a parallel set of rules, covered in our accounting guide, and medical practices have their own in our healthcare guide.

Programs in this post

See which buyers fit your company

Eight quick questions against every program in our buyer index. Participating buyers may pay us referral fees.